CENTRIFUGAL COMPRESSORS - NON INTEGRALLY GEARED vs INTEGRALLY GEARED

courtesy by KOBELCO

ADVANTAGES & DISADVANTAGES - NON INTEGRALLY GEARED vs INTEGRALLY GEARED

Centrifugal compressors are widely used in industrial plants in the oil, gas, and petrochemical industries for various applications. They can be classified as non-integrally geared or integrally geared based on their design. Here are the differences, advantages, and disadvantages of each type:

  1. Non-Integrally Geared Centrifugal Compressors:

    • Design: Non-integrally geared centrifugal compressors have a single impeller directly connected to the driver (typically an electric motor or a gas turbine).
    • Advantages:
      • Simplicity: Non-integrally geared compressors have a simpler design with fewer rotating parts, making them easier to operate and maintain.
      • Lower Cost: They generally have lower initial capital costs compared to integrally geared compressors.
      • Compact Size: Non-integrally geared compressors are usually more compact and require less space.
    • Disadvantages:
      • Limited Operating Range: Non-integrally geared compressors have a narrower operating range, making them less flexible in handling varying flow rates and pressures.
      • Lower Efficiency: They tend to have slightly lower efficiency compared to integrally geared compressors, especially at part-load conditions.

  2. Integrally Geared Centrifugal Compressors:

    • Design: Integrally geared centrifugal compressors have multiple impellers arranged in series and connected by a gearbox.
    • Advantages:
      • Wide Operating Range: Integrally geared compressors can handle a broader range of flow rates and pressures, making them suitable for applications with varying process conditions.
      • High Efficiency: They offer higher efficiency, especially at part-load conditions, due to the ability to optimize impeller speeds with the gearbox.
      • Improved Reliability: The gearbox allows for better load distribution and reduced stresses on the impellers, resulting in improved reliability and longer service life.
    • Disadvantages:
      • Higher Cost: Integrally geared compressors generally have higher initial capital costs due to the complexity of the gearbox.
      • Larger Size: They require more space compared to non-integrally geared compressors.
      • Increased Maintenance: The gearbox requires regular maintenance, including lubrication and inspection, adding to the maintenance requirements.

When to Use:

  • Non-Integrally Geared Compressors: These compressors are suitable for applications with a relatively constant operating point, where simplicity and lower capital cost are priorities.
  • Integrally Geared Compressors: They are preferred for applications with varying operating conditions, where higher efficiency, wider operating range, and improved reliability are critical.

Where to Use:

  • Both types of compressors are used in various applications within the oil, gas, and petrochemical industries, including gas processing, refining, petrochemical plants, and pipeline compression stations.

The selection between non-integrally geared and integrally geared compressors depends on factors such as process requirements, operating conditions, budget, and reliability considerations. A thorough analysis of the specific application, including flow rates, pressure ratios, turndown requirements, and lifecycle costs, is essential in determining the most suitable compressor type for a particular project or existing plant. Consulting with experienced compressor manufacturers and engineering consultants can provide valuable insights and guidance in making the appropriate selection.

LIMITATIONS IN ENGINEERING & DESIGN - NON INTEGRALLY GEARED vs INTEGRALLY GEARED

When considering the limitations in engineering and design of centrifugal compressors, both non-integrally geared and integrally geared compressors have certain factors that need to be taken into account. These limitations can impact the reliability, avoidance of critical failures, and environmental impacts in both existing plants and new projects in the oil, gas, and petrochemical industries. Here are some key limitations to consider:

  1. Non-Integrally Geared Centrifugal Compressors:

    • Limited Operating Range: Non-integrally geared compressors typically have a more limited operating range compared to integrally geared compressors. They may have challenges handling varying flow rates and pressures efficiently.
    • Turndown Ratio: Non-integrally geared compressors may have limitations in achieving a high turndown ratio, which is the ability to adjust the flow rate over a wide range. This can affect flexibility in meeting changing process demands.
    • Lower Efficiency at Part-Load: Non-integrally geared compressors may exhibit lower efficiency at part-load conditions compared to integrally geared compressors. This can result in higher energy consumption and environmental impacts.

  2. Integrally Geared Centrifugal Compressors:

    • Complexity and Cost: Integrally geared compressors are generally more complex in design, particularly due to the inclusion of a gearbox. This complexity can lead to higher initial capital costs, increased maintenance requirements, and potentially more complex troubleshooting.
    • Space Requirement: Integrally geared compressors tend to require more space compared to non-integrally geared compressors due to the inclusion of a gearbox.
    • Gearbox Reliability: The presence of a gearbox introduces an additional component that requires careful engineering and maintenance. The reliability of the gearbox is critical for the overall reliability of the compressor system.

To address these limitations and improve the reliability, avoidance of critical failures, and environmental impacts, it is essential to consider the following measures:

  1. Robust Design and Engineering:

    • Conduct a thorough analysis of the process requirements and operating conditions to select the appropriate compressor type (non-integrally geared or integrally geared) that aligns with the specific project needs.
    • Implement advanced engineering techniques, such as computational fluid dynamics (CFD) and finite element analysis (FEA), to optimize the design and performance of the compressor system.
    • Ensure compliance with relevant industry standards and codes to enhance safety and reliability.

  2. Proper Maintenance and Monitoring:

    • Implement a comprehensive maintenance program that includes regular inspections, lubrication, and condition monitoring of critical components, including the gearbox for integrally geared compressors.
    • Utilize advanced monitoring systems, such as vibration analysis and performance monitoring, to detect any potential issues and address them proactively.

  3. Adequate Training and Competence:

    • Ensure that personnel involved in the operation, maintenance, and troubleshooting of centrifugal compressors receive proper training and possess the necessary competence.
    • Establish clear procedures and protocols for operation, maintenance, and emergency shutdowns to minimize risks and ensure efficient and safe operations.

By considering these factors and implementing appropriate engineering and maintenance practices, the limitations associated with centrifugal compressors, whether non-integrally geared or integrally geared, can be effectively managed. This leads to improved reliability, avoidance of critical failures, reduced environmental impacts, and increased overall performance in both existing plants and new projects.

courtesy by INGERSOLL RAND

WHY, WHEN, WHERE, WHAT & HOW TO APPLY NON INTEGRALLY GEARED vs INTEGRALLY GEARED

To effectively apply centrifugal compressors, whether non-integrally geared or integrally geared, in industrial plants in the oil, gas, and petrochemical industries, with the aim of improving reliability, avoiding critical failures and risks, and minimizing environmental impacts, the following considerations should be taken into account:

  1. WHY:

    • Reliability Improvement: Both non-integrally geared and integrally geared centrifugal compressors can contribute to improved reliability by employing robust designs, proper maintenance practices, and monitoring systems.
    • Critical Failure Avoidance: Centrifugal compressors play a vital role in many industrial processes. By selecting the appropriate type and implementing suitable maintenance strategies, the risk of critical failures can be minimized.
    • Environmental Impact Reduction: Proper compressor selection, design optimization, and energy-efficient operation contribute to reducing the environmental footprint of the plant, including energy consumption and greenhouse gas emissions.

  2. WHEN:

    • New Projects: The selection of centrifugal compressors should be made during the design phase of a new plant or facility. Consideration should be given to the process requirements, operating conditions, turndown ratio, and energy efficiency goals.
    • Existing Plants: Upgrading or retrofitting existing plants with more efficient or reliable centrifugal compressors can be considered when aiming to improve overall system performance and reduce risks.

  3. WHERE:

    • Centrifugal compressors are widely used in various applications within the oil, gas, and petrochemical industries, including gas processing, refining, petrochemical plants, and pipeline compression stations.

  4. WHAT:

    • Selection of Compressor Type: Evaluate the specific requirements of the application, such as flow rates, pressure ratios, turndown requirements, and efficiency goals, to determine whether a non-integrally geared or integrally geared compressor is more suitable.
    • Design Optimization: Employ engineering techniques, such as computational fluid dynamics (CFD) and finite element analysis (FEA), to optimize the design and performance of the compressor system.
    • Maintenance Strategies: Implement a comprehensive maintenance program that includes regular inspections, lubrication, and condition monitoring of critical components, ensuring proper maintenance of both the compressor and associated systems.

  5. HOW:

    • Collaborate with experienced compressor manufacturers and engineering consultants who can provide expertise in compressor selection, design optimization, and maintenance strategies.
    • Adhere to industry standards, codes, and regulations to ensure compliance, safety, and reliability.
    • Continuously monitor and evaluate system performance, making necessary adjustments and improvements to enhance reliability and minimize risks.

By carefully considering these aspects and applying appropriate strategies, the use of centrifugal compressors, whether non-integrally geared or integrally geared, can lead to improved reliability, avoidance of critical failures and risks, reduced environmental impacts, and enhanced overall performance in both existing plants and new projects within the oil, gas, and petrochemical industries.

PROCEDURES, ACTIONS, STUDIES, MITIGATION, RECOMMENDATIONS TO APPLY - NON INTEGRALLY GEARED vs INTEGRALLY GEARED

To improve the reliability, avoid critical failures and risks, and minimize environmental impacts when using centrifugal compressors, both non-integrally geared and integrally geared, in industrial plants in the oil, gas, and petrochemical industries, the following procedures, actions, studies, mitigations, and recommendations can be implemented:

  1. Compressor Selection:

    • Conduct a thorough analysis of process requirements, including flow rates, pressure ratios, turndown requirements, and efficiency goals, to determine the most suitable compressor type (non-integrally geared or integrally geared) for the application.
    • Consider factors such as reliability, maintenance requirements, footprint, and overall system design when selecting a compressor.

  2. Engineering Design and Optimization:

    • Perform detailed engineering studies, such as computational fluid dynamics (CFD) simulations and finite element analysis (FEA), to optimize the design and performance of the compressor system.
    • Evaluate factors such as impeller design, volute configuration, sealing arrangements, and bearing systems to enhance reliability and efficiency.
    • Consider system integration and compatibility with other equipment and processes within the plant.

  3. Maintenance Strategies:

    • Develop a comprehensive maintenance program that includes regular inspections, lubrication, and condition monitoring of critical components.
    • Implement preventive maintenance actions, such as vibration analysis, oil analysis, and thermography, to detect early signs of potential failures.
    • Follow the manufacturer’s recommended maintenance practices and guidelines.

  4. Monitoring and Control Systems:

    • Install advanced monitoring and control systems to continuously monitor the performance and condition of the compressor.
    • Utilize real-time data and analytics to detect anomalies, predict failures, and optimize the operation of the compressor system.
    • Implement a remote monitoring system for off-site monitoring and diagnostics.

  5. Training and Competence:

    • Ensure that personnel involved in operating, maintaining, and troubleshooting the compressor system receive proper training and have the necessary competence.
    • Provide ongoing training to keep employees updated with the latest advancements in compressor technology, maintenance practices, and safety procedures.

  6. Mitigation of Environmental Impacts:

    • Optimize the compressor system for energy efficiency to minimize energy consumption and reduce carbon emissions.
    • Consider the use of variable frequency drives (VFDs) or speed control mechanisms to match the compressor output to the process demand, thereby reducing energy waste.
    • Implement noise reduction measures, such as acoustic enclosures or barriers, to mitigate noise pollution.

  7. Compliance and Safety:

    • Adhere to industry standards, codes, and regulations to ensure compliance and safety in the design, installation, and operation of the compressor system.
    • Conduct regular safety audits and risk assessments to identify potential hazards and implement necessary safety measures.

  8. Continuous Improvement:

    • Establish a culture of continuous improvement by conducting regular reviews and assessments of the compressor system’s performance.
    • Document and analyze any failures or incidents to identify root causes and implement corrective actions.
    • Stay updated with industry advancements and emerging technologies to identify opportunities for improvement.

By implementing these procedures, actions, studies, mitigations, and recommendations, industrial plants in the oil, gas, and petrochemical industries can enhance the reliability, mitigate critical failures and risks, minimize environmental impacts, and optimize the performance of centrifugal compressors, whether non-integrally geared or integrally geared, in both existing plants and new projects.

courtesy by ATLAS COPCO
CONTACT US