IMPACTS BY STRUCTURAL RESONANCE - TURBOMACHINERY

Courtesy by SOLAR TURBINES
Courtesy by SIEMENS
Courtesy by HOWDEN

CENTRIFUGAL COMPRESSORS

GAS TURBINES

SPECIAL STEAM TURBINES

Structural resonance in turbomachinery, including centrifugal compressors, gas turbines, and steam turbines, can have critical impacts on the reliability, availability, safety, and performance of these machines in various industries such as oil, gas, and power generation. Let’s explore the effects of structural resonance in both normal and offset operating conditions.

  1. Reliability and Availability:

    • Structural resonance can lead to increased vibration levels in turbomachinery, which may result in accelerated wear and fatigue of components such as blades, rotors, and casings. This can reduce the reliability and availability of the machinery, leading to more frequent maintenance and downtime.
    • Resonance-induced vibrations can cause unexpected failures, resulting in unplanned shutdowns and disruptions in production. These disruptions can have significant financial implications for the plant operators.

  2. Safety:

    • Excessive vibrations caused by structural resonance can compromise the integrity of the turbomachinery and its supporting structures. This can lead to mechanical failures, such as blade or rotor fractures, which pose safety risks to personnel and nearby equipment.
    • Severe vibrations can also result in increased stresses on the machine’s foundation, leading to potential structural failures and risks to the overall plant safety.

  3. Performance:

    • Resonance-related vibrations can negatively impact the overall performance of turbomachinery. Increased vibration levels can cause a loss in efficiency by affecting the aerodynamic performance of compressor or turbine blades, resulting in reduced output and increased energy consumption.
    • Vibrations can also lead to changes in clearances and alignments, affecting the operating parameters of the machine, such as flow rates, pressure ratios, and temperature differentials. This can further impact the performance and efficiency of the turbomachinery.

  4. Existing and New Plants:

    • In existing plants, structural resonance issues may arise due to changes in operating conditions, degradation of components, or modifications in the surrounding infrastructure. Identifying and addressing these resonance concerns is crucial to maintaining the reliability and performance of the existing machinery.
    • For new plants, proper design and engineering practices are essential to mitigate the risks associated with structural resonance. Analytical tools such as finite element analysis, computational fluid dynamics, and modal analysis can be used during the design phase to identify potential resonance frequencies and optimize the machine’s dynamic behavior.

To manage the critical impacts of structural resonance in turbomachinery, industry practices include:

  • Conducting regular vibration monitoring and analysis to detect and diagnose resonance-related issues.
  • Implementing appropriate maintenance and inspection programs to identify and rectify potential resonance problems.
  • Employing advanced control systems and active damping techniques to suppress or mitigate vibrations.
  • Incorporating robust design practices and considering dynamic characteristics during the engineering phase.
  • Applying modifications or retrofits to address resonance concerns in existing machinery.

By proactively addressing structural resonance issues, industries can improve the reliability, availability, safety, and performance of turbomachinery in oil, gas, and power generation plants.

LIMITATIONS IN ENGINEERING & DESIGN FOR STRUCTURAL RESONANCE IN TURBOMACHINERY

While engineering and design practices play a crucial role in mitigating the critical impacts of structural resonance in turbomachinery, there are certain limitations that need to be considered. These limitations can affect the ability to completely eliminate resonance-related issues and address their impacts on reliability, availability, safety, and performance. Here are some key limitations:

  1. Complexity of Dynamic Behavior:

    • Turbomachinery systems are complex, involving multiple components, rotating parts, and fluid interactions. Understanding and predicting the dynamic behavior of these systems, including resonance frequencies and mode shapes, can be challenging.
    • The interaction between rotating and stationary components, such as blades, casings, and shafts, can introduce additional complexities in predicting and managing structural resonance. The dynamic behavior of these components may change under different operating conditions, making it difficult to accurately assess the resonance risks.

  2. Uncertainties in Operating Conditions:

    • Operating conditions, such as flow rates, temperatures, and pressure differentials, can vary in turbomachinery systems. These variations may lead to changes in the resonance characteristics and vibration levels.
    • Predicting the exact operating conditions that can lead to resonance can be challenging, particularly in dynamic environments or when the machinery is subjected to transient conditions. Uncertainties in these conditions make it difficult to develop comprehensive designs that completely eliminate resonance concerns.

  3. Limitations in Modeling and Analysis:

    • Modeling turbomachinery systems for resonance analysis requires simplifications and assumptions due to the complexity of the system. These simplifications can introduce uncertainties in the accuracy of the analysis and may not capture all possible resonant modes.
    • Analytical tools and techniques used for resonance analysis, such as finite element analysis and modal analysis, have their own limitations. These methods rely on assumptions and idealizations that may not fully capture the dynamic behavior and complexity of turbomachinery systems.

  4. Design Constraints and Cost Considerations:

    • Designing turbomachinery systems to eliminate or mitigate structural resonance may be constrained by various factors such as space limitations, cost considerations, and performance requirements.
    • Reducing resonance risks often involves implementing design changes, such as modifying the geometry, adding damping mechanisms, or altering materials. These changes may have cost implications and could affect other aspects of the machinery’s performance or efficiency.

  5. Retrofitting Challenges in Existing Plants:

    • Retrofitting existing turbomachinery systems to address resonance concerns can be challenging due to constraints such as limited access to the machinery, compatibility with existing infrastructure, and potential disruption to plant operations during modifications.
    • Retrofitting solutions may require significant engineering efforts and resources, which can make them less practical or feasible for certain existing plants.

Despite these limitations, engineering and design practices continue to evolve to better address the critical impacts of structural resonance in turbomachinery. Advances in computational modeling, simulation techniques, and material science are helping to improve the accuracy of resonance predictions and the effectiveness of mitigation strategies. Additionally, ongoing research and industry collaborations aim to develop standardized guidelines and best practices for managing structural resonance in turbomachinery systems.

Courtesy by KOBELCO
Courtesy by SIEMENS
Courtesy by SHIN

WHY, WHEN, WHERE, WHAT, WHICH, HOW ABOUT STRUCTURAL RESONANCE

  1. Why:

    • Structural resonance in turbomachinery can cause critical impacts due to the dynamic interactions between the components of the machine. Resonance occurs when the natural frequencies of the machine coincide with the excitation frequencies, resulting in amplified vibrations.
    • The impacts of structural resonance include increased wear, fatigue, and potential failure of components, leading to reduced reliability, availability, and safety. Resonance can also negatively affect the performance and efficiency of turbomachinery, leading to decreased output and increased energy consumption.

  2. Where:

    • Structural resonance can occur in various components of turbomachinery, including blades, rotors, casings, and supporting structures. These components can exhibit different resonant frequencies and mode shapes, depending on their geometry, material properties, and boundary conditions.
    • Resonance can be localized within specific components or propagate throughout the entire machine, affecting its overall operation and integrity.

  3. When:

    • Structural resonance can occur during both normal and offset operating conditions. Normal operating conditions refer to the typical range of operational parameters, such as flow rates, temperatures, and pressure differentials, under which the machinery is designed to operate.
    • However, structural resonance can also be triggered during offset operating conditions, which deviate from the normal operating range. Changes in operational parameters, variations in fluid dynamics, or modifications in the surrounding infrastructure can introduce resonance risks.

  4. What:

    • The critical impacts of structural resonance include increased vibrations, accelerated wear and fatigue of components, potential failures, reduced reliability, availability, safety risks, decreased performance, and efficiency.
    • Excessive vibrations can lead to mechanical failures, such as blade or rotor fractures, compromising the safety of personnel and nearby equipment. Resonance-induced vibrations can also affect the aerodynamic performance of blades, resulting in reduced output and increased energy consumption.

  5. Which:

    • The critical impacts of structural resonance can affect various turbomachinery used in oil, gas, and power generation industries. This includes centrifugal compressors, gas turbines, and special steam turbines.
    • These machines play vital roles in processes such as compression, power generation, and energy conversion, making their reliable and safe operation crucial for the overall performance of plants in these industries.

  6. How:

    • Managing the critical impacts of structural resonance involves several strategies. These include conducting vibration monitoring and analysis, implementing maintenance and inspection programs, employing advanced control systems and active damping techniques, incorporating robust design practices, and applying modifications or retrofits to address resonance concerns.
    • Analytical tools such as finite element analysis, computational fluid dynamics, and modal analysis are used to identify resonance frequencies, assess risks, and optimize the dynamic behavior of turbomachinery.

By addressing the why, where, when, what, which, and how aspects of structural resonance in turbomachinery, industries can develop effective strategies to mitigate the critical impacts, ensuring improved reliability, availability, safety, and performance of their plants in the oil, gas, and power generation sectors.

PROCEDURES, ACTIONS, STUDIES, ANALYSIS, MITIGATIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS ABOUT STRUCTURAL RESONANCE IN TURBOMACHINERY

  1. Procedures and Actions:

    • Conduct regular vibration monitoring and analysis to detect and diagnose resonance-related issues. This involves installing appropriate sensors and collecting vibration data at strategic locations on the machinery.
    • Implement maintenance and inspection programs to identify and rectify potential resonance problems. This includes regular inspections of components, such as blades, rotors, casings, and supporting structures, to detect signs of wear, fatigue, or damage.
    • Establish a comprehensive risk management plan that includes procedures for assessing and mitigating resonance risks in both normal and offset operating conditions. This plan should outline responsibilities, escalation protocols, and mitigation strategies.

  2. Studies and Analysis:

    • Perform modal analysis to identify the natural frequencies and mode shapes of the turbomachinery components. This analysis helps identify potential resonant frequencies and the corresponding vibration modes.
    • Utilize finite element analysis (FEA) and computational fluid dynamics (CFD) to simulate and analyze the dynamic behavior of turbomachinery systems. These tools can help identify resonance risks, assess the impacts of design changes, and optimize the machine’s dynamic characteristics.
    • Conduct transient analysis to evaluate the dynamic response of the turbomachinery under varying operating conditions, including startup, shutdown, and load changes. This analysis helps identify potential resonance issues during transient states.

  3. Mitigations:

    • Implement active damping techniques, such as active magnetic bearings or active vibration control systems, to suppress or mitigate vibrations caused by structural resonance. These systems actively monitor and control vibrations, reducing the risk of resonance-induced failures.
    • Apply passive damping mechanisms, such as tuned mass dampers, dampening coatings, or vibration isolation mounts, to absorb or dissipate energy from resonant vibrations. These mechanisms can be integrated into the design of the turbomachinery or retrofitted onto existing components.
    • Optimize the design of turbomachinery components by considering dynamic characteristics and resonance avoidance during the engineering phase. This may involve modifying the geometry, materials, or structural configurations to shift resonance frequencies away from the operating range.

  4. Recommendations:

    • Foster collaboration and knowledge-sharing among industry professionals, researchers, and equipment manufacturers to exchange best practices and lessons learned in managing structural resonance.
    • Incorporate a culture of continuous improvement by monitoring and analyzing resonance-related incidents and implementing corrective actions.
    • Develop standardized guidelines and industry codes addressing structural resonance risks in turbomachinery design, operation, and maintenance. These guidelines should cover various types of turbomachinery and consider different operating conditions.
    • Consider the use of advanced diagnostic techniques, such as non-destructive testing, to detect early signs of resonance-related issues and proactively address them before they escalate.
    • Prioritize education and training programs for engineers and operators involved in the design, operation, and maintenance of turbomachinery to enhance their understanding of structural resonance risks and mitigation strategies.

By following these procedures, taking appropriate actions, conducting studies and analysis, implementing mitigations, and following recommendations, the oil, gas, and power generation industries can effectively address the critical impacts of structural resonance in turbomachinery, ensuring improved reliability, availability, safety, and performance in existing and new plants.

CONTACT US