LONG TERM SERVICES AGREEMENTS (LTSA) vs FIELD REPAIR MAINTENANCE CREW - CENTRIFUGAL COMPRESSORS

WHY, WHEN, WHERE, WHAT, WHICH, HOW TO APPLY THE LTSA vs FIELD REPAIR MAINTENANCE CREW

When considering the criteria of long-term service agreements (LTSAs) vs. field repair by maintenance crew for centrifugal compressors in plants, the following factors should be taken into account:

  1. Why:

    • Improve reliability: Both LTSAs and field repair can contribute to improving the reliability of centrifugal compressors by ensuring regular maintenance and prompt repairs.
    • Enhance availability: Proper maintenance and timely repairs help minimize unplanned downtime, maximizing the availability of the compressors.
    • Enhance safety: Well-maintained compressors are less likely to experience safety-related issues such as leaks or malfunctions, ensuring a safer working environment.
    • Avoid critical risks and failures: Through proactive maintenance and repairs, the risks of critical failures and associated consequences can be minimized.

  2. When:

    • Existing plants: Both LTSAs and field repair are applicable in existing plants where centrifugal compressors are already in operation. The choice depends on factors such as the age of the equipment, maintenance history, and performance requirements.
    • Preventive maintenance: LTSAs are typically implemented as preventive maintenance strategies, aiming to identify and address potential issues before they escalate. Field repair can be utilized for both preventive and corrective maintenance as required.

  3. Where:

    • Oil, gas, and petrochemical industries: Centrifugal compressors are commonly used in these industries for various applications, including gas processing, refining, and petrochemical production. Therefore, the criteria can be applied in plants within these sectors.

  4. What:

    • LTSAs: Implementing an LTSA involves engaging a service provider or the equipment manufacturer to provide comprehensive maintenance, repair, and support services. This includes regular inspections, scheduled maintenance activities, performance monitoring, and access to OEM-approved spare parts.
    • Field repair by maintenance crew: This approach involves establishing an in-house maintenance crew or contracting external specialists to handle maintenance and repair activities on an ad-hoc basis. The crew should be equipped with the necessary tools, diagnostic equipment, and expertise to perform maintenance and troubleshooting tasks.

  5. Which:

    • Choosing between LTSAs and field repair depends on factors such as the complexity of the compressor system, available resources, budget considerations, and the desired level of control over maintenance activities. Critical factors may include the criticality of the compressor to the plant operations and the expertise of the in-house maintenance team.

  6. How:

    • Evaluate service providers: For LTSAs, evaluate the capabilities, track record, and reputation of potential service providers. Consider their experience with centrifugal compressors and their ability to meet the specific needs of your plant.
    • Assess in-house capabilities: If opting for field repair by maintenance crew, assess the capabilities of the in-house team or external contractors. Ensure they have the necessary technical expertise, training, and access to equipment and spare parts.
    • Define maintenance plans: Develop comprehensive maintenance plans that outline the frequency of inspections, routine maintenance activities, and performance monitoring. These plans should be aligned with the recommendations provided by the equipment manufacturer.
    • Establish communication channels: Establish clear communication channels between the plant operators, maintenance crew, and service providers. This ensures effective coordination, timely reporting of issues, and efficient resolution of maintenance and repair tasks.
    • Track performance: Monitor the performance of the compressors regularly to identify any recurring issues or emerging risks. Use performance indicators such as efficiency, vibration levels, and operating parameters to assess the effectiveness of the chosen maintenance approach.
    • Continuous improvement: Continuously review and improve maintenance practices based on lessons learned and industry best practices. Regularly update maintenance plans and consider incorporating predictive maintenance techniques to further enhance reliability and reduce downtime.

PROCEDURES, ACTIONS, STUDIES, MITIGATION, RECOMMENDATIONS TO APPLY THE LTSA vs FIELD REPAIR MAINTENANCE CREW SERVICES IN CENTRIFUGAL COMPRESSORS

To apply the criteria of long-term service agreements (LTSAs) vs. field repair by maintenance crew services in existing plants for centrifugal compressors, and to improve reliability, availability, safety, and mitigate critical risks and failures in the oil, gas, and petrochemical industries, the following procedures, actions, studies, mitigations, and recommendations can be considered:

  1. Procedures:

  2. a. Assess the current maintenance practices: Conduct a thorough assessment of the existing maintenance practices for centrifugal compressors in the plant. Identify strengths, weaknesses, and areas for improvement.

  3. b. Evaluate equipment criticality: Determine the criticality of the centrifugal compressors to the overall plant operations. This assessment helps prioritize resources and decide on the appropriate maintenance approach.

  4. c. Identify the scope of work: Define the specific tasks and services required for maintaining the centrifugal compressors. This includes routine maintenance, inspections, repairs, spare parts management, and performance monitoring.

  5. d. Develop maintenance plans: Based on the identified scope of work, develop comprehensive maintenance plans that outline the frequency, procedures, and responsibilities for each maintenance activity. Align these plans with equipment manufacturer recommendations and industry best practices.

  6. e. Establish communication protocols: Ensure clear communication channels between the plant operators, maintenance crew, and potential service providers. Set up reporting mechanisms for timely identification and resolution of maintenance issues.

  7. Actions:

  8. a. Determine the appropriate approach: Evaluate the suitability of LTSAs vs. field repair by maintenance crew services based on factors such as equipment complexity, criticality, available resources, and expertise of the in-house maintenance team.

  9. b. Engage service providers: If opting for LTSAs, identify reputable service providers with expertise in centrifugal compressors and experience in the oil, gas, and petrochemical industries. Evaluate their capabilities, track record, and ability to meet specific plant requirements.

  10. c. Develop in-house maintenance capabilities: If choosing field repair by maintenance crew, assess the skills and expertise of the existing maintenance team. Provide training and resources to ensure they are capable of performing maintenance and repair tasks effectively.

  11. d. Establish a spare parts management system: Develop a robust spare parts management system to ensure timely availability of critical components. Consider the use of OEM-approved spare parts or high-quality alternatives.

  12. e. Implement condition monitoring techniques: Integrate condition monitoring techniques such as vibration analysis, oil analysis, and thermography to detect potential issues and initiate timely maintenance interventions. This helps identify potential failures before they occur.

  13. f. Regular inspections and maintenance activities: Conduct regular inspections and routine maintenance activities as outlined in the maintenance plans. Adhere to the recommended maintenance intervals and procedures provided by equipment manufacturers.

  14. g. Document maintenance activities: Maintain detailed records of all maintenance activities, including inspections, repairs, and spare parts usage. This documentation helps track maintenance history, identify recurring issues, and support future decision-making.

  15. Studies:

  16. a. Failure analysis studies: Conduct failure analysis studies to identify common failure modes and root causes specific to centrifugal compressors in the oil, gas, and petrochemical industries. This knowledge can guide maintenance strategies and help prevent critical failures.

  17. b. Reliability studies: Perform reliability studies to assess the performance of the centrifugal compressors and identify areas for improvement. Analyze data related to equipment failures, downtime, and maintenance costs to optimize maintenance plans and resource allocation.

  18. Mitigation:

  19. a. Risk assessment and mitigation: Conduct regular risk assessments to identify potential safety, environmental, and operational risks associated with the centrifugal compressors. Develop mitigation plans to address these risks and prevent critical failures.

  20. b. Contingency planning: Develop contingency plans to handle unexpected equipment failures or maintenance delays. This ensures minimal disruption to plant operations and helps maintain safety and availability.

  21. Recommendations…

  1. Evaluate equipment criticality: Assess the criticality of the centrifugal compressors to plant operations. Focus resources and prioritize maintenance efforts based on the criticality level.

  2. Conduct a cost-benefit analysis: Compare the costs and benefits of LTSAs and field repair services. Consider factors such as maintenance costs, equipment downtime, spare parts availability, and the expertise of the maintenance crew.

  3. Engage reputable service providers: If opting for LTSAs, choose service providers with proven expertise in centrifugal compressors and experience in the oil, gas, and petrochemical industries. Evaluate their track record, capabilities, and ability to meet plant-specific requirements.

  4. Develop in-house maintenance capabilities: If choosing field repair by maintenance crew, invest in training and resources to enhance the skills and expertise of the maintenance team. Ensure they are equipped with the necessary tools and knowledge to perform maintenance and repairs effectively.

  5. Implement condition monitoring techniques: Integrate condition monitoring techniques such as vibration analysis, oil analysis, and thermography to detect potential issues early on. This allows for timely maintenance interventions, reducing the risk of critical failures.

  6. Establish a spare parts management system: Develop a robust spare parts management system to ensure timely availability of critical components. Consider using OEM-approved spare parts or reliable alternatives to maintain equipment performance and reliability.

  7. Adhere to manufacturer recommendations: Follow the maintenance guidelines and recommendations provided by equipment manufacturers. This includes adhering to recommended maintenance intervals, procedures, and inspections.

  8. Document maintenance activities: Maintain detailed records of all maintenance activities, including inspections, repairs, and spare parts usage. This documentation helps track maintenance history, identify recurring issues, and support future decision-making.

  9. Foster communication and collaboration: Establish clear communication channels between plant operators, maintenance crew, and service providers. Encourage open dialogue and collaboration to ensure effective coordination and timely resolution of maintenance issues.

  10. Continuously improve maintenance practices: Regularly review and evaluate maintenance practices based on lessons learned, industry best practices, and emerging technologies. Incorporate new approaches, technologies, and predictive maintenance techniques to enhance reliability, availability, and safety.

  11. Conduct periodic assessments: Perform periodic assessments of maintenance effectiveness, equipment performance, and risks. This helps identify areas for improvement and make informed decisions regarding the optimal maintenance strategy.

ADVANTAGES & DISADVANTAGES BETWEEN THE LTSA vs FIELD REPAIR CREW SERVICES

Advantages of Long-Term Service Agreements (LTSAs):

  1. Expertise and specialized support: LTSAs often involve collaboration with OEMs or qualified service providers who possess extensive knowledge and expertise in the specific make and model of the centrifugal compressor. Their specialized support can lead to more efficient and effective maintenance and repair processes.
  2. Predictable costs: LTSAs typically offer a fixed or predictable cost structure, allowing for better budgeting and financial planning. This eliminates the need for unexpected expenses associated with emergency repairs or component replacements.
  3. Proactive maintenance: LTSAs often include scheduled preventive maintenance activities, such as regular inspections, cleaning, and component replacements. This proactive approach can help identify and address potential issues before they escalate into critical failures, improving reliability and avoiding unexpected downtime.
  4. Enhanced warranty coverage: LTSAs often provide extended warranty coverage for specific components or systems. This can offer additional protection against failures and reduce the financial burden of repairs or replacements.
  5. Access to spare parts and resources: LTSAs usually include provisions for the availability of genuine OEM spare parts, ensuring their timely delivery and reducing the risk of using counterfeit or substandard components. Additionally, LTSAs may provide access to technical resources, such as technical documentation and training materials, further enhancing maintenance capabilities.

Disadvantages of Long-Term Service Agreements (LTSAs):

  1. Higher costs: LTSAs generally come with higher upfront or periodic costs compared to field repair services. This can be a significant financial burden, especially for plants with limited budgets or cost constraints.
  2. Dependency on external providers: Engaging in LTSAs means relying on external service providers for maintenance and repair activities. This can limit the plant’s flexibility and control over the maintenance processes, as they are bound by the terms and conditions of the agreement.
  3. Limited customization: LTSAs often follow standardized maintenance protocols and schedules, which may not perfectly align with the specific requirements of the plant or the operating conditions of the centrifugal compressor. This can result in suboptimal maintenance practices or missed opportunities for customization.
  4. Potential for delays: Depending on the terms of the agreement and the availability of service personnel or spare parts, there may be delays in response time or repair activities. This could impact the availability and reliability of the compressor, particularly during critical situations.
  5. Contractual complexities: LTSAs involve complex contractual agreements that need to be carefully reviewed and negotiated. Understanding and managing the terms, conditions, and performance guarantees within the agreement can be challenging.

Advantages of Field Repair by Maintenance Crew Services:

  1. Control and flexibility: With field repair services, the plant’s maintenance crew has direct control and flexibility over the maintenance and repair processes. They can adapt and customize the procedures based on the specific needs of the plant and the operating conditions of the compressor.
  2. Lower costs: Field repair services typically have lower upfront costs compared to LTSAs. This can be advantageous for plants with limited budgets or those seeking to optimize their maintenance expenses.
  3. Quick response time: In emergency situations or for urgent repairs, field repair services offer faster response times as the maintenance crew is readily available on-site. This minimizes downtime and improves the availability of the compressor.
  4. In-house expertise development: By performing field repairs in-house, the maintenance crew can develop and enhance their expertise and skills in maintaining and repairing the centrifugal compressor. This can lead to better knowledge retention within the organization and increased self-sufficiency.
  5. Direct communication and collaboration: Field repair services allow for direct communication and collaboration between the maintenance crew and other plant personnel. This facilitates knowledge sharing, problem-solving, and a deeper understanding of the specific requirements and challenges of the plant.

Disadvantages of Field Repair by Maintenance Crew Services for Centrifugal Compressors:

  1. Limited expertise and resources: Maintenance crews may not have the same level of expertise and specialized knowledge as OEMs or external service providers. They may lack access to the latest technical information, specialized tools, or advanced diagnostic equipment required for complex repairs.

  2. Time and skill constraints: Maintenance crews may already be occupied with other routine maintenance activities, leaving limited time and resources for extensive repairs or troubleshooting. Lack of specialized training or experience in specific compressor models can also pose limitations on their ability to effectively address complex issues.

  3. Risk of improper repairs: Inadequate training or limited experience in specific compressor models can lead to improper repairs or diagnostic errors. This can further worsen the condition of the compressor or introduce new risks, potentially resulting in critical failures or safety hazards.

  4. Resource limitations: Maintenance crews may face limitations in terms of available spare parts, tools, or equipment required for certain repairs. This can prolong the repair process or result in temporary fixes that may not be as reliable or durable as OEM-recommended solutions.

  5. Safety considerations: Complex repairs or major overhauls may involve working with hazardous materials or in high-risk environments. Without proper expertise and safety protocols, there is an increased risk of accidents or incidents during field repair activities.

 

The scope for long term services agreements

  • Scheduled Maintenance
  • Unscheduled Maintenance
  • Initial Spare Parts
  • Yearly Spare Parts Replenishment
  • Yearly Audit Services (including borescope inspections)
  • Engineering Support
  • Yearly Training
  • Software Upgrades
  • Preferred Lease Rates
  • Onsite Technician
  • Availability Guarantee and associated bonus/liquidated damage provisions
  • Remote Monitoring Services
CONTACT US