MAINTENANCE PHILOSOPHIES - GAS TURBINES

ADVANTAGES & DISADVANTAGES USING DIFFERENT MAINTENANCE PHILOSOPHIES IN GAS TURBINES

Advantages:

  1. Preventive Maintenance:

    • Advantages:
      • Enhances reliability by proactively addressing potential failure points and implementing routine inspections and maintenance activities.
      • Extends the lifespan of gas turbines by preventing premature failures.
      • Reduces the likelihood of unscheduled downtime, thereby improving availability and productivity.
      • Enhances safety by identifying and rectifying potential safety hazards during regular maintenance.
    • Considerations:
      • It may lead to increased maintenance costs due to regular inspections and maintenance activities.
      • It may not detect certain failure modes that are not evident through routine inspections alone.

  2. Predictive Maintenance:

    • Advantages:
      • Enables condition-based maintenance, allowing for targeted and efficient maintenance actions based on real-time equipment data.
      • Minimizes downtime by identifying potential failures before they occur, improving availability and operational efficiency.
      • Optimizes maintenance resource allocation and reduces unnecessary maintenance activities, thereby reducing costs.
    • Considerations:
      • Requires specialized monitoring techniques and equipment to gather and analyze data.
      • Initial investment in monitoring systems and training may be required.
      • Some failure modes may not exhibit clear precursors, making prediction challenging.

  3. Reliability-Centered Maintenance (RCM):

    • Advantages:
      • Maximizes reliability by identifying critical failure modes specific to gas turbines and implementing appropriate maintenance strategies.
      • Optimizes maintenance intervals based on the criticality and consequences of failure, thereby minimizing downtime and enhancing availability.
      • Reduces the likelihood of catastrophic failures, enhancing safety and minimizing environmental risks.
    • Considerations:
      • Requires a comprehensive understanding of gas turbine failure modes and associated risks.
      • Implementation may involve complex analysis and decision-making processes.
      • Regular review and updates are necessary to account for changes in equipment and operating conditions.

  4. Total Productive Maintenance (TPM):

    • Advantages:
      • Involves all stakeholders in maintenance activities, fostering a culture of ownership and accountability.
      • Improves gas turbine effectiveness and productivity through autonomous and planned maintenance actions.
      • Enhances communication and collaboration between maintenance and operations teams, leading to improved overall performance.
    • Considerations:
      • Requires cultural and organizational changes to embrace TPM principles.
      • Initial training and implementation efforts may be time-consuming and resource-intensive.
      • Alignment and coordination across different departments and shifts may be challenging.

  5. Risk-Based Maintenance (RBM):

    • Advantages:
      • Prioritizes maintenance activities based on risk assessments, optimizing resource allocation and focusing on high-risk equipment and failure modes.
      • Reduces the likelihood of critical failures, enhancing safety and avoiding environmental risks.
      • Aligns maintenance efforts with safety and environmental objectives.
    • Considerations:
      • Requires comprehensive risk assessments and data analysis capabilities.
      • May involve complex decision-making processes and require specialized expertise.
      • Continuous monitoring and reassessment of risks are necessary to ensure effectiveness.

It’s important to note that the advantages and considerations mentioned above are general in nature. The specific benefits and challenges of implementing maintenance philosophies can vary depending on factors such as the type of gas turbine, operational conditions, and the organization’s existing maintenance practices.

By carefully considering the advantages and potential considerations of each maintenance philosophy, organizations can select and implement the most suitable approaches to enhance reliability, maintainability, availability, and safety in their gas turbines, thereby avoiding environmental risks and critical failures or unscheduled shutdowns.

WHY, WHEN, WHERE, WHAT, WHICH, HOW TO APPLY DIFFERENT MAINTENANCE PHILOSOPHIES IN GAS TURBINES

  1. Why Apply Different Maintenance Philosophies?

    • Gas turbines are critical assets in power generation, oil, gas, and petrochemical industries, and their reliable operation is vital for productivity and safety.
    • Different maintenance philosophies help improve reliability by addressing potential failure points, enhancing maintainability, and reducing the likelihood of critical failures or unscheduled shutdowns.
    • By implementing maintenance philosophies, organizations can optimize availability, minimize downtime, and ensure the safe operation of gas turbines, thus reducing environmental risks associated with unexpected failures.

  2. When to Apply Different Maintenance Philosophies?

    • Maintenance philosophies can be applied throughout the lifecycle of gas turbines, including during the design, construction, commissioning, operation, and decommissioning phases.
    • It is beneficial to incorporate maintenance considerations from the early stages of new projects to ensure the design and selection of appropriate maintenance strategies.
    • For existing industrial plants, maintenance philosophies can be implemented during regular maintenance cycles or during major overhaul or retrofitting projects.

  3. Where to Apply Different Maintenance Philosophies?

    • Different maintenance philosophies can be applied to gas turbines used in power generation plants, oil refineries, petrochemical facilities, and gas processing plants.
    • They are relevant for both onshore and offshore installations, depending on the specific application and industry requirements.

  4. What are the Different Maintenance Philosophies?

    • The different maintenance philosophies include preventive maintenance, predictive maintenance, reliability-centered maintenance (RCM), total productive maintenance (TPM), and risk-based maintenance (RBM).
    • Preventive maintenance involves scheduled inspections and maintenance activities to prevent failures.
    • Predictive maintenance relies on condition monitoring techniques to identify potential failures before they occur.
    • RCM focuses on identifying critical failure modes and implementing appropriate maintenance strategies based on the consequences of failure.
    • TPM involves involving all stakeholders in maintenance activities to improve overall equipment effectiveness and productivity.
    • RBM prioritizes maintenance based on risk assessments to focus on high-risk equipment and failure modes.

  5. Which Maintenance Philosophy to Choose?

    • The choice of maintenance philosophy depends on factors such as the criticality of the gas turbine, the consequences of failure, the available resources, and the organization’s goals and capabilities.
    • Organizations may choose to implement a combination of maintenance philosophies tailored to their specific needs and industry requirements.

  6. How to Apply Different Maintenance Philosophies?

    • Implementing maintenance philosophies involves several steps, including:
      • Conducting a thorough assessment of the gas turbine’s operational context, failure modes, and associated risks.
      • Selecting and implementing appropriate maintenance strategies based on the chosen philosophy, such as developing preventive maintenance schedules, deploying condition monitoring systems, or conducting risk assessments.
      • Training and educating maintenance personnel on the chosen philosophy and equipping them with the necessary skills and tools.
      • Establishing a feedback loop to monitor the effectiveness of maintenance actions, review performance, and continuously improve maintenance strategies.

By applying different maintenance philosophies, organizations can enhance the reliability, maintainability, availability, and safety of gas turbines in existing industrial plants and for new projects in power generation, oil, gas, and petrochemical industries. This helps to avoid environmental risks, minimize critical failures, and prevent unscheduled shutdowns, thereby ensuring the efficient and sustainable operation of gas turbines.

PROCEDURES, ACTIONS & RECOMMENDATIONS - MAINTENANCE PHILOSOPHIES

There are several maintenance philosophies that can be applied to gas turbines in order to improve their reliability, maintainability, availability, and safety. Here are some common maintenance philosophies and the procedures, actions, and recommendations that can be applied to each:

  1. Reactive maintenance: This is a “run-to-failure” approach where maintenance is only performed after a failure has occurred. While this may be the cheapest approach in the short-term, it can result in increased downtime, lost production, and increased repair costs.

Procedures/actions:

  • Document failures and their causes
  • Track downtime and repair costs
  • Determine if there are any recurring failure modes

Recommendations:

  • Develop a plan to address recurring failure modes
  • Consider a proactive maintenance approach to prevent failures from occurring in the first place
  1. Preventive maintenance: This is a scheduled maintenance approach where maintenance is performed at predetermined intervals. This can help to reduce the risk of failure and increase the overall reliability of the equipment.

Procedures/actions:

  • Develop a maintenance schedule based on manufacturer recommendations and/or experience
  • Perform visual inspections and measurements to check for wear and tear
  • Replace components that are approaching their end-of-life or that show signs of wear and tear

Recommendations:

  • Use condition monitoring techniques to identify potential issues before they become critical
  • Monitor the performance of the equipment to identify trends and adjust maintenance schedules as needed
  1. Predictive maintenance: This is a maintenance approach that uses data and analytics to predict when maintenance is required. This can help to reduce maintenance costs and minimize downtime.

Procedures/actions:

  • Install sensors and data collection systems to monitor equipment performance
  • Use analytics to identify patterns and trends in the data
  • Develop models to predict when maintenance is required

Recommendations:

  • Use machine learning and artificial intelligence to improve the accuracy of predictions
  • Develop a comprehensive plan for collecting and analyzing data
  • Use predictive maintenance in conjunction with other maintenance approaches for a comprehensive maintenance strategy
  1. Reliability-centered maintenance (RCM): This is a maintenance approach that focuses on optimizing maintenance tasks to improve reliability and reduce maintenance costs.

Procedures/actions:

  • Identify critical equipment and failure modes
  • Determine the consequences of failure
  • Develop maintenance tasks to prevent or mitigate failures

Recommendations:

  • Use a risk-based approach to prioritize maintenance tasks
  • Continuously review and update the RCM plan based on changing conditions and new information
  1. Total productive maintenance (TPM): This is a maintenance approach that involves all employees in the maintenance process to maximize the productivity of the equipment.

Procedures/actions:

  • Develop a culture of ownership and accountability for equipment maintenance
  • Train employees on maintenance procedures and techniques
  • Implement an ongoing improvement program to identify opportunities for improvement

Recommendations:

  • Develop a comprehensive training program for employees
  • Foster a culture of continuous improvement
  • Use TPM in conjunction with other maintenance approaches for a comprehensive maintenance strategy

In conclusion, the specific procedures, actions, and recommendations to be applied to gas turbines will depend on the maintenance philosophy being used. By implementing a comprehensive maintenance strategy that incorporates multiple maintenance philosophies, the reliability, maintainability, availability, and safety of gas turbines in industrial plants can be significantly improved.

FREQUENT QUESTIONS & ANSWERS - MAINTENANCE PHILOSOPHIES - GAS TURBINES

Here are some of the most frequent questions and answers asked about different maintenance philosophies related to gas turbines in the oil, gas, and petrochemical industries:

  1. What is reactive maintenance, and when is it appropriate for gas turbines?

Reactive maintenance involves waiting until a piece of equipment fails before performing maintenance or repairs. It is generally not recommended for gas turbines as it can lead to unplanned downtime and more costly repairs. However, it may be appropriate for less critical or easily replaceable components.

  1. What is preventive maintenance, and when is it appropriate for gas turbines?

Preventive maintenance involves performing maintenance on a schedule, typically based on manufacturer recommendations or industry best practices. It is appropriate for gas turbines when there are known failure modes or wear mechanisms that can be mitigated through routine maintenance, such as changing filters, lubricating bearings, or checking alignment.

  1. What is condition-based maintenance, and when is it appropriate for gas turbines?

Condition-based maintenance involves monitoring the condition of equipment through various techniques, such as vibration analysis or oil analysis, and performing maintenance or repairs when specific thresholds or indicators are reached. It is appropriate for gas turbines when there are specific failure modes or wear mechanisms that can be detected through monitoring and mitigated through targeted maintenance.

  1. What is risk-based maintenance, and when is it appropriate for gas turbines?

Risk-based maintenance involves assessing the risks associated with equipment failure and prioritizing maintenance activities accordingly. It is appropriate for gas turbines when there are specific failure modes or wear mechanisms that pose a significant risk to safety, the environment, or production, and when the costs of failure are high.

  1. What is reliability-centered maintenance, and when is it appropriate for gas turbines?

Reliability-centered maintenance involves analyzing the functions and performance requirements of equipment and developing a maintenance strategy that maximizes reliability and availability. It is appropriate for gas turbines when there are complex or critical systems that require a comprehensive understanding of the equipment and its failure modes.

  1. What is total productive maintenance, and when is it appropriate for gas turbines?

Total productive maintenance involves involving all personnel in the maintenance and improvement of equipment and processes, with a focus on continuous improvement and waste reduction. It is appropriate for gas turbines when there are opportunities to optimize performance or reduce waste through collaboration and engagement of all stakeholders.

  1. What are some of the key benefits and drawbacks of different maintenance philosophies for gas turbines?

The key benefits of different maintenance philosophies include increased reliability, reduced downtime and repair costs, and improved safety and environmental performance. However, each approach has its drawbacks, such as increased costs associated with more frequent or specialized maintenance activities, or the risk of missing important maintenance activities or failure modes. It is important to select a maintenance philosophy that aligns with the specific needs and goals of the organization and equipment.

CONTACT US